Persecuted in China and unwanted in Korea: trials and tribulations of China's Christian minority
SEOUL — On April 21, 2008, the day Chen Mo had been fearing finally arrived: The native of China’s central Henan Province was arrested by local police.Chen, then 25, was tortured and beaten, he said.
Chen’s crime was belonging to the Church of Almighty God (CAG), a Chinese Christian religious movement that that country’s government has labeled as an “evil cult” that is a threat to state security.
After being jailed for five years, he fled to South Korea. Now he – like hundreds of other members of his church in exile here – live in terror of being deported back to China, where it is likely he will be jailed again.
“We want to go back," he said. "But we have to wait until China has freedom of religion.”
Chen and other church members held a press conference in Seoul this week that coincided with a release of a report claiming thousands of church members have been arrested in China.
The Church, which started in 1991, has an estimated four million members in China. Its followers believe that Jesus Christ has returned and is incarnated as a Chinese woman: She is not publicly named by the Church, but scholars identify her as Yang Xiangbin, a woman born in 1973 in northwestern China and now believed to be living in the United States.
Their religious practice centers around a minimalist style of worship that includes reading from The Word Appears in the Flesh, which they believe to be the word of God, singing hymns, sharing testimonies and hearing sermons.
They do not practice any of the traditional Christian sacraments, believing that those belong to a previous era of Christianity.
The Church of Almighty God is on China’s list of xie jiao, or cults that are seen as a threat to state security. Like members of other groups targeted by the Chinese government — including Falun Gong and Uighur Muslims — members of the Church of Almigthy God say they are persecuted.
Chen said he spent five years in prison, being forced to undergo frequent indoctrination sessions.
“I lost the best years of my youth there,” he said.
Church member Mo Xiufeng is currently serving a 9 year sentence in prison, according to the Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission, a bi-partisan group made up of members of the U.S, House of Representatives.
According to a March 20 report published by the Church, more than 11,000 CAG members were arrested in China in 2018 alone – and 20 died as a result of mistreatment.
The report is self-published and figures are impossible to verify. But Massimo Introvigne, founding director of the Italy-based Center for Studies on New Religions said he found the numbers credible based on Chinese media accounts.
“Chinese media report almost weekly that hundreds of members of the Church have been arrested in one province or another,” he said.
The US State Department’s Human Rights Report 2018, released in March, singled out China for its extreme human rights violations and noted the “systematic torture in custody” of members of the Church of Almighty God.
The group claims that at least 400,000 of its members were arrested between 2011 and 2017.
“The Church of Almighty God is often referred to by the Chinese Communist Party as the ‘new Falun Gong,’” said Introvigne, who has written a book on the Church that will be published by Oxford University Press.
Introvigne said the church has expanded to a significant size from its origins among the small “house churches” of the 1980s as small “house churches,” and also that it does not follow the state-sanctioned Three-Self Patriotic Movement and China Christian Council.
That growth has led to a crackdown.
“'You should not grow’ is the main message to any religious movement in China,” said Introvigne.
After his release from prison, Chen said he stayed in hiding, constantly moving homes until an opportunity to escape came in 2016, and he fled to South Korea’s Jeju Island – a resort destination that offers visa-free tourist entry for mainland Chinese.
But freedom has remained elusive for Chen and nearly 1,000 other asylum seekers from the CAG who have been fled to South Korea.
All of them have filed asylum claims, but none have been approved by the South Korean government.
“They’ve lost everything – houses, families, jobs,” said Rosita Soryte, a former Lithuanian diplomat, who is president of the International Observatory of Religious Liberty of Refugees. “They are not full members of society anywhere, here they live in limbo. These people need to find a place to stay, because (South) Korea is not giving them asylum and they cannot go home.”
Church members fear that they will be immediately arrested if they are deported to China.
Many report that their relatives back home remain under constant threat and surveillance, and say the Chinese government has continued to monitor and harass them in South Korea.
While Church of Almighty God members have found refuge in some 30 other countries including the US, Canada, Taiwan, Australia, New Zealand and several EU countries, South Korea has proven particularly resistant to allowing asylum claims.
Last year, large protests broke out over 500 Yemeni refugees who landed on Jeju Island.
The Chinese Church of Almighty God members have not inspired the same public outcry but officials have not been sympathetic to their requests.
An official from the Jeju Island Immigration Office told the Korea Times last year that the Church members “didn't provide detailed, credible explanations on how they were actually persecuted in China. They just claimed they had concerns that they might be persecuted had they stayed there."
Intovigne notes that they have also faced opposition from other Christian groups in South Korea, which is 29 percent Christian, according to a 2014 PewResearch study.
“In Korea, there is a strong Christian opposition to heterodox groups,” he said.
A Korean website called churchheresy.com has written against the CAG and argues members should be denied asylum. Small protests at their church and online harassment campaigns have dogged the CAG members as well.
The group has been accused in China of abducting and brainwashing followers and committing acts of violence.
In 2014, religious missionaries murdered a customer in a McDonald’s in Shandong: After the perpetrators were captured, authorities declared them CAG members.
The Church has denied the claim. Some scholars, including Introvigne, were able to access the trial transcripts and concluded that the killers were not members of CAG.
Meanwhile, the Church of Almighty God members continue to practice their faith in South Korea under a cloud of uncertainty. They’ve opened four churches in the country and have attracted roughly 100 Korean members.
You Xin, a 26-year-old member who fled from Ningbo, Zhejiang province in 2015, said she keeps busy with Church activities and hobbies such as taking photographs but is limited by her uncertain status.
“I can’t work, I can’t study,” she said. “I don’t have access to medical insurance.”
Beneath a cheerful demeanor, she said that troubled thoughts are never far away.
“I have nightmares about being on the run, about missing a flight,” she said. “Every day we hear that persecution is getting worse and worse in China. We are very much in fear and very much unsettled.”
Photo: March 20, 2019 - Seoul, South Korea - Painting representing the founding of the Church of Almighty God in China, presented at a display inside their church in Seoul, South Korea, where many members have fled from China in recent years seeking asylum.
Credit: Thomas Maresca/ ARA Network Inc. (03/20/19)
Story/photo publish date: 03/25/19
A version of this story was published in Religion News Service.
